When embracing open innovation, you need to identify procured or pushed-out seeds (ideas, technologies, products, etc.) through considering your various strategies or corporate culture (How to Implement Open Innovation Activities - Basic Edition [Analyze Your Company]).
This article shows reference materials which are useful to think about open innovation strategy consisting of several activities. Two matrix were developed in order to help to draw the strategy.
The Innovation Matrix
Satell proposes a matrix to organize innovation activities of companies:Domain Definition:Who is the best placed to solve it?
- Sustaining Innovation
- Increases revenue by improving current products or services incrementally
- Large organizations are very good at this type of innovation because of conventional R&D labs and outsourced suppliers
- Breakthrough Innovation
- Needs combinations of ideas including closely related fields
- Should make multidisciplinary teams when tackling in-house
- Useful to implement contests with prize awards
- Disruptive Innovation
- Explores new business models leveraging strengths
- Needs iterative process with trial and error
- Could change the basis of competition
- Basic Research
- Normally funded by the government and undertaken by academic institutions
- Some companies, like IBM or Microsoft, invest in to attract world-class talent
- Most of companies send internal researchers to conferences and work closely with the offices of technology transfer to substitute for in-house activities
- You have to be seen as a participant rather than just an observer to gain access to top-quality research
Companies must detect the combination of four innovations suitable for their business model, corporate strategy or culture and allocate their resources. As each innovation needs different method, you have to make appropriate decision.
Archetypes of Open Innovation Modes
The Narsalay's guideline about when and how to use each of the four basic modes of open innovation using the problem complexity and whether the location of the knowledge sought is known or hidden, was shown before (Methods of Open Innovation [Classification by Problem Complexity and Knowledge Hiddenness]):- Traditional IP contract
- Licensing of IP in the market and used when a single partner owns a particular technology
- Has been used for decades as a conventional method of collaboration
- Open innovation partnership
- Bilateral relationship and used when problem complexity is high and the location of technology to solve the problem is known
- Can be applied when the candidates for collaboration partners are identified
- Open innovation platform/contest
- Taps into a large number of problem solvers who potentially have relevant know-how to solve the problem and used when the problem is easy to explain and there is no clue about the solution
- Requires a company to publish proprietary information broadly
- Open innovation community
- Collaborations among several participants and used when problem complexity is high and interactive process is necessary to solve the problem
- Must collect potent individuals or organizations to set up the community
The classification above consists of two axes derived from problems and solutions as with the Satell's matrix. It proposes appropriate method suitable for the types of projects and is used for different purpose from Satell's matrix.
Business Strategy Matrix and Current Business Matrix
Satell's matrix enables to discuss resource allocation for current and new businesses. Narsalay's classification is useful for selecting the method of open innovation. However, both are not sufficient to consider open innovation strategy.In order to solve this problem, two matrix were developed.
Business strategy matrix organizes business activities by two axes of company's competences and business models. The competence and the business model are defined as "a combination of multiple resources including knowledge, technologies, or know-how" and "business strategy and profit model about products or services," respectively.
Current business matrix is the focused part of current business in business strategy matrix and have two axes of needs and seeds. The needs and the seeds are defined as "idea of products or services to meet customers' needs" and "ideas, technologies, or products to realize the needs," respectively. The resources allocated to current businesses are devoted to four categories again.
When implementing activities in fact, you need to select an appropriate option from various methods of open innovation (Methods of Open Innovation)
Organizing Needs, Seeds, Competences and Business Models
When the goal of open innovation activities is to strengthen current businesses, first you should organize needs and seeds in your company. There are two kinds of needs: ones which customers recognize at this point and ones which they have not yet. The analytical methods using questionnaire survey, customer voice, sales information, or big data are useful to identify them.The collected needs can be dealt with the following process:
- Prioritize the needs
- Create product or service concepts
- Identify technical challenges which are needed to be solved in order to develop products or services
- Search technologies inside your company
- Procure them outside your company
In addition, before thinking about new business development or intelligence activities, it is better to organize competences and business models. The book by Gassmann which classifies successful business models into 55 patterns, is useful for idea creation of latter.
cf. Gassmann O, Frankenberger K, Csik M (2014) The Business Model Navigator, Pearson, Harlow
Collaboration Partners of Open Innovation
When considering the method of open innovation using both matrix, expected collaboration partners must be selected from the following:- Employees
- Customers
- Suppliers
- Competitors
- Venture capitals
- Universities/research institutes
The collaboration with specific partners could lead to a high internal resistance. If this is the case, you should start with the second-best option and try them again after making achievements.
Concluding Remarks
This article introduced two matrix which are useful to consider open innovation strategy. As new methods of open innovation will be created in the future, the best combination for your company could change. Therefore, it is recommended to add open innovation to the intelligence target of the business strategy matrix.If you have any opinion or question, please do not hesitate to contact the following address (thomas.openinnovation@gmail.com).
Unauthorized copying and replication prohibited.
Useful Reference - Floyd C (1997) Managing Technology for Corporate Success, Gower Publishing, Hampshire
- Base technologies
- Essential to be in the business
- Entry hurdles but do not give significant competitive advantage
- Can be sourced from external entities easily
- Should be actively outsourced because of the flexibility and saving time and cost
- Key technologies
- Have high competitive impact on critical product performance or cost of sales ratio
- Have been utilized by some companies
- Should not be outsourced to avoid increased risk
- Pacing technologies
- Tomorrow's key technologies
- Under experimentation by some companies
- Should be developed under collaboration with external entities to share the cost
- Emerging technologies
- At early research stage or emerging in other industries
- Competitive impact unknown
- Should be developed under collaboration with external entities to share the cost
- Clear leader
Decide the development speed of technologies and the direction in the industry - Strong
Can implement independent technology development and create new direction - Favorable
Can maintain technology competitiveness or show leadership in niche technology - Tenable
Cannot decide independent direction - Weak
Cannot maintain the quality of technology output and are chased by short-term emergency responses




0 件のコメント :
コメントを投稿