(Open Innovation Lecture-17e)
Open Innovation Community

This page is written based on the original article.

This article discusses open innovation community as a method of open innovation. 

What is Open Innovation Community?

Brunswicker defined open innovation community as follows:

Firms setup their own community to solve innovation problems in a collaborative manner with a group of individuals and organizations who share a common innovation vision

cf. Brunswicker S, Bagherzadeh M, Lamb A, Narsalay R, Jing Yu (2016) Managing Open innovation projects with impact, Research Center For Open Digital Innovation, Purdue University, West Lafayette, Indiana

The big difference to open innovation contest explained before is that there are knowledge interactions between administrators and participants or among participants in the community. As a result, it is suitable for when tackling complicated problems. Participants can be motivated by "learning of new technologies or market trends," "gains of reputation," "risk or cost sharing when tackling innovation," and so on.

When implementing open innovation community by own, the fundamental flow and the points to be considered are as follows:
  • Determine the Target Field
  • Organize Needs and Seeds in the Target Field
    • Update periodically
  • Set the Guideline on Intellectual Property
    • Distinguish information that may be or must not be disclosed to community members outside your organization
    • Determine the ownership ratio for idea creators
  • Select the Types of Community Members
    • Consumers, experts, employees, etc.
  • Invite Community Members
  • Run the Community

    Lessons Learned from Past Cases

    In Brunswicker's report, the effectiveness of open innovation community was shown through the case studies of Evonik, Eli Lilly, and Ford. However, in spite that many companies recognize the high value of this method, they have not implemented yet or started without any plan followed by miserable failures.

    Johnston classified the practices of open innovation community into four stages through the experience of Dell’s IdeaStorm:
    • The Social Suggestion Box
      • Community members are welcome to submit any idea or feedback
      • No fixed process dealing with them
    • Overwhelming Backlog
      • A large pile of unread ideas
      • Community members are irritating because of the slow or no response of administrators
      • Most companies never make it beyond this stage
    • Managed Sprints
      • Administrators shape specific challenges and direct ideas 
      • Ideas are considered in the appropriate management process quickly
      • The feedback from product development team is returned
    • Collaborative Innovation
      • Ideas derived from the community lead to new products or services
      • Both of the organization and community members are satisfied

    Even Dell’s IdeaStorm recognized as a successful case had a challenging situation. Since launched in 2007, year 3 found it as a miserable condition
    with no leadership, vision or community management. A community member posted the idea that Dell should shut IdeaStorm down and the community quickly upvoted it. However, the leadership of CEO, Michael Dell enabled to move to the next stage.

    Dahlander showed that most of organizations do not receive a sufficient number of proposals from online community members.

    The summary is as follows:
    • There has been little research analyzing the challenges derived from the participation of various external contributors (individuals) in open innovation initiatives
    • It is difficult to elicit proposals from external contributors and average organizations accumulate only one per month (success cases such as Dell, Starbucks, or NASA are limited)
    • This study analyzed the data of 24,000 organizations that used the online tool and received at least one proposal 
    • It was found that the following methods can be used to elicit more proposals:
      • Proactive attention
        Stimulates discussions by showing internal ideas
      • Reactive attention
        Sends the signal to respect proposals from external contributors
    • Most of actions are done by a few members in online communities
    • In addition to existing members, organizations need to pay particular attention to newcomers who can consider challenges from the fresh standpoint and retain them in the community
    • Organizational intervention in the early stage of initiatives enables to determine the long-term direction of the community
    cf. Dahlander L, Piezunka H (2014) Open to suggestions: How organizations elicit suggestions through proactive and reactive attention, Research Policy, 43 (5), 812-827

    How to elicit proposals is more important than how to deal with a lot of them. Activities to increase the number of community members or active involvement should be continued until the community will be activated to some extent 

    There was a startup company focusing on open innovation community for product development. Quirky, founded in 2009, built a community of over a million members and commercialized over 100 products. They raised over 180 million USD in venture capital funding, but went bankrupt in 2015.

    From this case, four lessons when implementing open innovation community were obtained:
    • The product development projects supported by many people do not create breakthrough
    • Producing high quality products requires focus on limited number of them and continued improvement over time
    • A broad range of product categories inhibits to achieve an economy of scale
    • Responding to the expectation of community members too much leads to slow decision making

    Past cases suggest not to implement this method easily. It is necessary to prepare measures to increase the probability of success and to have a commitment to spend sufficient resources.

    Use of External Services

    Open innovation community can be built using the services of open innovation intermediaries such as yet2.com or innovation management softwares such as Qmarkets. The advantages compared to implementing by own are effective platform based on best practices, IP risk aversion, or workload reduction. The fact that global companies including Unilever, General Mills, DSM, or GSK are using those services implies their worth. 

    In Japan, Wemake provides the service to exploit the power of community for product development of their clients and the cases of KOKUYO or Olympus are shown in the following article.

    cf. http://ascii.jp/elem/000/001/478/1478670/

    When implementing open innovation community, not only ideas derived from it but also the list of community members are valuable. They are regarded as the consumers who are interested in your products or the experts who make contributions to technology/product development, and thus are precious asset for your business activities. In the case of using intermediaries, it is better to confirm whether profile information about community members can be obtained or not in advance.

    Concluding Remarks

    Just like other methods, some trials and errors are needed to create meaningful output from open innovation community. In an earlier article, several metrics for open innovation portal site were shown (Metrics of Open Innovation [Metrics to Track for Open Innovation Portal Site]). Reviewing the activities with such a metrics periodically enables to maintain your motivation for improvement.

    This method needs longer time and is more difficult to implement than open innovation contest. However, it is sufficiently valuable in terms of creating ideas under the environment where needs and seeds have not been identified.

    Tom

    If you have any opinion or question, please do not hesitate to contact the following address (thomas.openinnovation@gmail.com).
    Unauthorized copying and replication prohibited.

    0 件のコメント :

    コメントを投稿