(Open Innovation Lecture-2e)
Open Innovation and Crowdsourcing

This page is written based on the original article.

This article explains the difference of two concepts, open innovation and crowdsourcing, which are often confused.

Definition of Crowdsourcing

Crowdsourcing is a coined word derived from crowd and sourcing. It was defined by Jeff Howe who was an editor of WIRED in 2006:

Crowdsourcing represents the act of a firm or institution taking a function once performed by employees and outsourcing it to an undefined (and generally large) network of people in the form of an open call.

cf. Howe J (2006) Wired Blog Network: Crowdsourcing

Although various people use different definitions, it is common that problems are outsourced to an unknown or anonymous group of solvers by an open call. The internet-enabled information sharing realized to target an undefined crowd and this point is different from conventional outsourcing.

Classification of Crowdsourcing

Crowdsourcing is classified into several methods from various viewpoints. For example, Hossain shows the following three methods which are often used:
  • Idea contests
    • Held online normally
    • Common for large organizations that can use their own platform or intermediary platforms
    • A specific period of time for application and rewards to increase the motivation of applicants are often set
  • Idea generation by online communities
    • Creates ideas through bilateral interactions with a specific community
    • High quality output could be produced because the interaction can improve initial ideas
    • It is necessary to run a community efficiently
  • Microtasking
    • Small parts of a big task are outsourced to the crowd
    • Typical works are data entry or simple translation
    • The cost is very low and the time required is minimal
cf. Hossain M (2016) Embracing Open Innovation to Acquire External Ideas and Technologies and to Transfer Internal Ideas and Technologies, Doctoral Thesis, Aalto University, Helsinki, Finland

On the other hand, Sivula classifies by the targets (knowledge, resource or funding):
  • Knowledge focused crowdsourcing (Crowdknowledge)
    • Crowd wisdom:
      The crowd is employed to create new ideas or products
    • Crowdvoting:
      The crowd votes on the usability of an organization's new and old products or services
    • Crowdevaluation:
      The crowd evaluates new ideas or products
  • Resource focused crowdsourcing (Crowdsourcing)
    • Crowd creation:
      The crowd creates new products or services
    • Microtasking:
      The crowd performs simple works without any specific professional skills
    • Macrotasking:
      The crowd performs advanced works with specific professional skills
  • Funding focused crowdsourcing (Crowdfunding)
    • Crowdfunding of a project:
      The crowd provides funding for development of new products or services
    • Crowdfunding of an organization:
      The crowd provides funding for operation of organization with acquiring equity
    • Crowdfunding as a loan:
      The crowd offers peer-to-peer lending
cf. Sivula A (2016) Generic Crowdsourcing Model for Holistic Innovation Management, Doctoral Thesis, University of Vaasa, Vaasa, Finland

In the case of large organizations, not only external crowdsourcing but also internal one which targets different units or overseas branches is also effective. When knowledge are dispersed in organizations, crowdsourcing enables to overcome information silos and utilize the full potential of the organization crowd.

Difference Between Open Innovation and Crowdsourcing

In the previous article, it was written that open innovation is not a method, but a philosophy or mindset (Overview of Open Innovation). On the other hand, crowdsourcing is a method and thus the classification is different from that of open innovation. Although some people use the word "open innovation" instead of "idea contest" which is a kind of crowdsourcing, it is not accurate.

In the case of companies, there is a corporate philosophy first. The corporate strategy will come next and then the R&D strategy supports it. After that, you need to determine if open innovation is necessary or not. Only when open innovation is integrated into the corporate strategy, crowdsourcing will be considered as one of a series of actions.

Again, if to adopt open innovation or not should be considered based on the level of corporate strategy. When starting open innovation activities without doing that, you will not be able to overcome a lot of hurdles.

Concluding Remarks

Instead of using open innovation or crowdsourcing as buzzwords, learning their origins and definitions properly is a shortcut to success.

Tom

If you have any opinion or question, please do not hesitate to contact the following address (thomas.openinnovation@gmail.com).
Unauthorized copying and replication prohibited.

Useful Reference - Higa K, Igawa K (2013) Impact of Crowdsourcing

This is a book to summarize how individuals or companies should adapt to circumstances where crowdsourcing is common.

The author shows the words of people in large companies "we cannot use crowdsourcing to exploit external resources because we have excess amount of them inside the company." Then, the internal crowdsourcing to target employees are proposed.

In fact, multinational companies use an innovation management software and run ideation communities to utilize internal knowledge effectively. One of such software vendor is Qmarkets (http://www.qmarkets.net/) and more than 160 companies are using it. There is the name of Mitsubishi Electric as a Japanese company on their web page.

I have participated in the idea & innovation management software community of Qmarkets. It was simple and run as follows:
  1. Program owners define challenges and their requirements collected from various business units
  2. Participants propose solutions
  3. Other participants ask questions or comments to them
  4. Program owners close new applications
  5. Expert team evaluates solutions
  6. New projects start based on selected solutions 
Each participant has their own account and earns points by providing solutions or making comments. Active involvement leads to more points and ranks (such as platinum, gold, silver and bronze) are given. It is a kind of gamification.

Unfortunately, active users were limited to a part of employees. One colleague said that he will not propse his ideas because someone could steal them. Without a culture of collaboration, the introduction of a new system does not lead to any result.

0 件のコメント :

コメントを投稿