(Open Innovation News-78e)
Release of Third Edition of the White Paper on Open Innovation

This page is written based on the original article.

Third edition of the white paper on open innovation dealing with the current status and challenges of innovation creation in Japan is released. This paper was prepared based on the interviews or surveys until January 2020 when the influence of COVID-19 was limited.

Third Edition of the White Paper on Open Innovation Compiled
https://www.meti.go.jp/press/2020/05/20200529012/20200529012.html

The summary is as follows:
  • The questionnaire survey targeting about three hundred companies showed the following results:
    • More than 80 percent of large companies recognize that they create some kinds of innovation
    • The tendency to seek short-term output of R&D becomes stronger in the last five years
    • Many companies regard difficulty to take risks for new business development or M&A, ambiguity of strategy or vision, low penetration in organizations, and slow decision making as obstacles of innovation
    • Approximately 75 percent of companies implement open innovation activities at this point
    • Some companies identify collaboration partners and get ideas for new business through open innovation activities
  • While Japanese companies work on low-risk improvement of current products or services, initiatives to tackle innovative products, services, or technologies are not sufficient
  • Although companies which utilize open innovation effectively appear, understanding of merits and demerits or the level of activities are not sufficient
  • The following examples of innovation activities are shown:
    • Japanese companies:
      • Manufacturing industry:
        Pacific Engineering Corporation, HILLTOP, Tokyo Electron Limited, Nitride Semiconductors, Mitsui Chemicals, Mitsufuji Corporation, Daiichi Sankyo Company, Kobayashi Pharmaceutical
      • Service industry:
        HITACHI, Mercari, Rakuten, NTT DOCOMO, Nintendo, Seven & i Holdings
    • Overseas companies:
      Thermo Fisher Scientific・PayPal・Bayer・Merck・Cisco Systems・SAP・Deposit Solutions・Lenovo・DJI
    • Ecosystems:
      Shibuya-ku, Osaka-shi, MTZ, VentureOut, Silicon Valley Forum, DCI
  • The current status of innovation activities in Japan obtained from the survey is as follows:
    • Management:
      • Although the qualities of products or services are high, some companies are missing value creation based on their customers
      • The centralization of power on the top management team leads to slow decision making in business or product development due to time lags for employees
      • It is difficult to take risks
      • Open innovation does not be exploited because of the premise that there are technical capabilities in-house
      • It is necessary to cultivate skills or mindset of the top management team for innovation
      • There is not enough investment in innovation activities
    • R&D and IP:
      • The external technologies which have high value and are required for organizations cannot be assessed appropriately
      • There is a shortage of a business mind of academic or industrial researchers
    • Human resources:
      • The number of innovation leaders or intrapreneurs are insufficient
      • Low mobility of workers leads to inflexible employment
      • The most talented employees cannot be evaluated properly
    • Startups:
      • Only a few people have the entrepreneurial mindset
      • The ecosystem of startups are not mature
      • There is a few companies having global operations
    • Industry:
      • Japanese companies in various industries have higher than average competitiveness
      • Manufacturing companies have world-class technologies in specific areas
      • The technologies or other resources of large companies are piling up
    • Society:
      • There is a high interest in social challenges
  • Success factors based on the current status of Japan are as follows:
    • Growth potential by raising awareness of innovation creation and improving innovation activities
    • Growth potential of startup ecosystems
    • Capabilities or resources of manufacturing companies
    • Resources and value creation record of large companies
    • Plenty of opportunities for solving social challenges
  • Directions of activities by each organization or whole Japan are as follows:
    • Pursuing innovation, clarifying goals and objectives, and strengthening of effective and efficient initiatives by companies or research organizations
    • Transitioning business models by exploitation of various data, digitalization, or value creation through multiplication of products and services
    • Using assets, intellectual properties, or human resources of large companies effectively for whole Japan including startup companies and promoting growth of ecosystems 
    • Accelerating innovation by starting from various collaborations among industries, academia, governments, and citizens to solve social challenges
  • Key points for open innovation are as follows:
    • When implementing open innovation activities, it is necessary to consider the value creation first and to promote appropriate collaborations based on own resources instead of being captured with problem solving
    • It is important to leave some degrees of freedom strategically with adjusting speed to collaboration partners instead of being captured with handling of confidential information or governance

Build the Systems to Create Innovations Continuously

While it was written that many companies announce the importance of open innovation without substantial activities in first edition in 2016, second edition in 2018 showed the number of collaboration projects by active companies has increased (Release of Second Edition of the White Paper on Open Innovation). In addition, the objective of activities appears to be changed from strengthening R&D into creating new business. Third edition implies there are problems with the creation of innovations, although more companies adopt open innovation.

Unlike before, companies must create innovations continuously in order to survive in high uncertainty and rapid changing environment. It is essential to define appropriate portfolio, to compare it with current one, and to fill the gap between them. Since open innovation is only one of the means, companies need not only to implement open innovation activities, but also to consider in a broader framework.


Viki provides a system for large companies to create innovations continuously by lean startup methodology and named it as innovation ecosystem. It is divided into twelve components and each of them must be implemented step by step while enlightening employees including top management teams. Therefore, it is necessary to be patient for a long time until obtaining results.

cf. Viki T, Toma D, Gons E (2017) The Corporate Startup: How established companies can develop successful innovation ecosystems, Vakmedianet, 2017

Talented people are indispensable each on strategic, tactic, and execution layers to create innovations continuously (Growth Potential and Open Innovation of P&G [Human Resources Necessary for Implementing Open Innovation Activities]). They must bear a heavier burden when building innovation ecosystems because it is more comprehensive than open innovation activities. Will it be possible to maintain talented people on three layers during such a long period?

Shortly after being released, international standard on innovation management might play an important role (Impact of Quality Management Systems on Open Innovation [International Standard on Innovation Management - ISO56002]). Anyone who does not understand the necessity of innovation ecosystems can make a contribution to build them by aiming to obtain the certification. It will lead to decrease the dependency of human resources.

It seems to be natural that Japanese companies are struggling to create innovations because they cannot attract people necessary for building innovation ecosystems due to low mobility of workers or unsuitable evaluation of the most talented employees. However, if the number of companies facing financial difficulties because of COVID-19 increases, some of them might promote radical reform and could regenerate.

Tom

If you have any opinion or question, please do not hesitate to contact the following address (thomas.openinnovation@gmail.com).
Unauthorized copying and replication prohibited.

0 件のコメント :

コメントを投稿